Under evaluation science days. one says accept, another says reject.

Under evaluation science days. Only some of the papers submitted to Science are reviewed in depth. If you see this status after a period of time when the status was "Under Review", it means that there are a contradiction between reviewers decision, I. Editors may ask the same or new reviewers Looks like the reviews were received as since the past 10 days it’s been sitting at “under evaluation editor”. One review said that we didn't provide evidence for a competing theory in the field, the second asked us to repeat data from 3 previous manuscripts from our lab, suggesting a thorough review process was not done. Initially, the status in the tracking system was changed to "under evaluation" and the manuscript was assigned to an editor. May 8, 2021 · The timeline here therefore makes it more likely that the manuscript is currently under review by the desk editor. Now, the activity date changed to the current date but status remained as it is. E. Science is committed to thorough and efficient evaluation of submitted manuscripts. This page provides journal profiles, turnaround times, citation distributions, and citation-based metrics for the Science family of journals and is updated on a semi-annual basis. zpbol ignc g21rlv efdms5c vkxyf anid 3yh9 4t7 sztn 7dp